Learning Chinese
Children's Education July 11th, 2008
Image via WikipediaI came across this article by SignOnSanDiego.com titled “Kindergartners urged to learn key languages.” It highlights an elementary school in Fairfax stepping up to the call of Pres. Bush to “teach the youngest students Chinese and other foreign languages considered critical to the nation’s future security.” The program is called the National Security Language Initiative.
Besides Chinese, other languages regarded as “critical languages” are Arabic, Russian, Hindi and Farsi. However, it is reported that Chinese is the most popular because of the booming business in China. The U.S. Education Department encourages teaching of these languages even at kindergarten level and has allocated $26 million in grants to communities around the country.
The reason why this article caught my attention is because I am impressed that the U.S. education department has not only realized the value of learning languages like Chinese but has also taken active steps to make sure the schools provide the learning opportunity to the children.
Here in Malaysia, more and more parents also see the great value and advantage of learning chinese. I’m not just talking about the chinese people. Even the other races (Malays, Indians, “dan lain lain”) in Malaysia acknowledge the benefits of learning this language. Unfortunately, what seems to be the best option is packing our children into Chinese schools. Seeing that there is an exploding interest in learning Chinese, I wish our education department would also take active steps in providing this language development to our children in national schools.
Let’s take a quick look at this business of learning Mandarin in Malaysia. Like just mentioned, many believe the best way is for children to attend a Chinese school. However, Chinese school’s are also famous for their endless stream of homework. Listening to parents talk about their children doing homework till 11pm and losing out on their childhood is heartbreaking indeed. And unlike this school in Fairfax where children play Jeopardy to learn the language, I don’t think anyone has enthusiastically commented how fun it is to learn chinese in our schools. Let’s not forget how crowded it is getting too. One teacher to 50 students is far from ideal. Some parents like the idea of discipline in chinese schools. Unfortunately, it is the same “discipline” that is killing their creative natures.
So, it is really sad to me that Chinese schools are considered the best option for our children to acquire the chinese language. I, for one, believe there must be a better way.
Complaining will get us no where. Finding solutions is better use of our energy. Therefore, I’m calling all parents out there to put on their thinking cap and tell me, what do you think is a good way for our children to learn Mandarin?
Let me start the ball rolling:
1. Give children a choice to learn it in national schools like the P.O.L. (People’s Own Language) classes. My daughter attends a school which is 99.9% malay. The option of learning mandarin is not available to her. However, if mandarin was an option, like part of the school syllabus, I am sure many non-chinese will want to learn too.
2. Play groups. Not those high paying tuition or enrichment centres. Just mothers getting their children together to learn conversational skills, story telling and children songs.
Okay, I would like to hear your ideas now.















July 11th, 2008 at 11:29 pm
I like the idea of setting up playgroups. At least mother and children get to mingle around while learning. I bet learning chinese will fun this way!
Hi cookie,
Which child wouldn’t enjoy learning when there are stories to hear, songs to sing and games to play?
July 13th, 2008 at 3:27 am
Great blog, subscribed to your rss feed. Thanks.
July 13th, 2008 at 11:42 pm
For my opinion P.O.L. seem not enough to study Chinese well. It just likes Chinese ad student poor in Malay and English. Some even need to polish up their Malay and English by study one more year in remove. I think it’s sufficient to learn Chinese within the 6 primary years. After entering secondary they do have choice to skip Chinese.
vickylow’s last blog post..712 Gathering
Hi Vicky,
I guess what is sufficient depends on the parent’s expectation too. For me, I would like my children to learn some conversational skills. It’s okay if they cannot read and write. But for other parents, this is not enough.
July 14th, 2008 at 3:03 am
Hi Lian, I agreed with you that Mandarin has becomes a critical language in Malaysia nowadays. I am also working very hard to let Sean learn Mandarin even thinking of sending him to Chinese Primary School. But, the same concern, will it be too much of burden on them?
Having POL class at national school has been implemented long time ago, I am one of the example, it benefits me just a little while and because of lack of teacher and pupils, they stopped it. I am from a Chinese primary school, I loved Mandarin very much, till I changed to national school. My Mandarin level collapsed but still I learnt through my own initiative and interest. What I would like to say here is we must create an interest in them in order to learn Mandarin, playgroup is an excellent idea. I would definitely agree for us parents to start a Mandarin play group with all sorts of activities in Mandarin. It is not only benefits the kids but also sharpen the Mommies or Daddies’ minds in putting our effort together in teaching and learning Mandarin.
Those that not so good in Mandarin can learn from those that is good. I hope one day we can have this kind of play group in our area. But, due to distance, it makes us work harder. Just my 2 cents, hope it helps!
Alice’s last blog post..Home made clay
Hi Alice,
I believe it’s quite common that people’s Mandarin skill drop after they leave the chinese school. I hear that a lot. That kinda supports the idea that self interest and daily speaking are the 2 important factors when it comes to learning the language. Actually, I’m surprised that there’s not many Mandarin playgroups seeing that there is so much interest in pushing our children to learn the language. But like you said, it’s hard work to get something like this going.
July 15th, 2008 at 8:57 am
watch chinese sit-com or cartoon
huisia’s last blog post..Funny Jo
Hi HuiSia,
Chinese sit-com more for you izzit? Hehehe
July 16th, 2008 at 9:45 am
hi Lian,
i think starting a playgroup is a great idea, but with a stuctured programme.
it is not easy to learn chinese. it is not easy to attract children to learn chinese if the family it self doesn’t value chinese. i see kids attending chinese primary school but parents are helpless (don’t understand mandarin) into their studies. it makes the kids hate chinese eventhough they have the basic of it.
you can start teaching kids on the history and meaning of establishing each and every charaters? like, kid’s name. it was a pictogram and it is very meaningful to see how our mother tougue evolve.
i still cherish my chinese. i love it@pawchuen.spaces.live.com
good day to you.
pc’s last blog post..lately
Hi PC,
Yes, totally agree that chinese is not easy to pick up if you are not exposed to it at home. And even more difficult if you don’t have a love to learn it.
July 17th, 2008 at 12:38 am
The best way to pick up Mandarin language is actually practising it everyday. Watching Mandarin movies also help a great deal and that’s how I picked up my Mandarin.
My 2 older gals picked up Mandarin in just a short 1-2 months when my mil came back before I delivered my 3rd child. Now (after 3 mths), they speak rather fluent Mandarin and Alycia can even write her surname in Mandarin by hard!
Health Freak’s last blog post..Count Our Blessings, Lest We Forget
Hi Shireen,
I totally agree with you that daily speaking is the best way. I believe that’s another reason why most parents want to send their children to a chinese school coz’ then the child is immersed in the language.
July 18th, 2008 at 6:20 am
I visited a National school recently whose teacher informed me that in a pilot program, Mandarin in that school is being taught as a daily subject by a teacher who comes to the school starting for Year One students either last year or the year before. It is more than just a POL. He says if it is a success, it will continue. This pilot program according to the teacher is being implemented in certain schools (I guess in those Chinese populated areas). I think that is exactly what is needed to get the students back to the National Schools but whether it continues or is discontinued remains to be seen.
For learning the Chinese Language, I don’t think a playgroup environment is good enough.
mumsgather’s last blog post..How to organise a Conference
Hi Mumsgather:
It’s good to hear that such a program exists. I love that idea and really hope it is a success. Is it okay for me to ask what school is this?
Also, would love to hear you elaborate on why you say a playgroup environment is not enough?
July 19th, 2008 at 3:24 am
Pride. Pride of being a Chinese. If we can instil that mentality into the children’s mind, the interest will grow by itself.
I have a friend who went to national primary and secondary school. He not only learned how to speak, but read and write in Chinese by his own initiative. His reason - he’s a Chinese.
Not easy. But it’s one of the avenue, I think.
Buzzing J’s last blog post..What is LIFE?
Hi Buzzing J:
Well, there is good and bad to that kind of mentality. In a way, you are right. The child must have the love and passion for learning the language in the first place. You friend found a reason to fuel that passion. That reason may not work for everyone. It still comes down to the individual’s interest. For example, I know a friend who learned Mandarin on his own because he liked a Mandarin speaking girl.
July 20th, 2008 at 7:30 am
I came across this blog the other day and you got some great info here - thanks.
July 23rd, 2008 at 9:29 am
Hi, Lian and all other mums,
I have been looking hi and low on how to introduce chinese to my daughter in a fun way, even to the extent of buying dora the explorer (who speaks in mandarin) DVD from US. I just realise that that astro has introduced mandarin and bahasa language for the disney channels 612 and 615 starting this July. If you check on info box, you will see (DL) and that would mean that you can choose mandarin language option for the show. I think it’s a good and less stressful way to introduce mandarin to the children in shows that they enjoy. Try it and let me know. Fr, mei shi
Hi Mei Shi,
Unfortunately (or fortunately) I do not have Astro. But I think learning through tv is good as an introduction. At least they get to hear what it sounds like and maybe learn a few words. But of course to master the language it will take more than that. I believe the fastest way to pick up a language is to speak it everyday. For example, I learned my hokkien because I had to speak to my grandmother who was living with us.
August 12th, 2008 at 3:44 am
I agree with the comment that exposure to the language is important. I learned far more from my 6-month stay in China than in 10+ years studying Chinese in school.
jane’s last blog post..Breastfeeding Annoyances
August 18th, 2008 at 1:39 am
Well, im a new visitor and i think practise makes perfect, so yes, speaking the language with family, friends, while watching tv programs or even with neighbours or someone at the supermarket aisle would be a good start for my toddler.